FC Logo
     
       
   
About this site
Recent Reviews
Movies A to A
DVD and Video Reviews
Guest Reviews
Links
Contact Us

 

 

 

 

 

Gangs of NY
Gangs Of New York- 12/20/02 - R - 168m
Leonardo DiCaprio - Amsterdam Vallon
Daniel Day-Lewis - William "The Butcher" Cutting
Cameron Diaz - Jennie Everdeane
Director: Martin Scorsese

Red LightLYN

Okay class…attention please! Why do we tell a story? Perhaps it's to inform or maybe just to entertain? But what if the story isn't all that entertaining? Because in it's revealment it fails to show evidences in the least of any prevalent information? What if I were to regale you with a wondrous tale such as, I don't know, how about…"I went to the grocery store last Tuesday."? Not a very exciting saga, but informative nonetheless. But, what was the point? Exactly! There wasn't one. And with that in mind, I give you "Gangs of New York".
The film starts out quite intriguingly enough with the dawn of cold winter's morn and the smell of impending death in the air. The combatants agreed on the prize, cry havoc and let slip the dogs of war. With a crescendo of Verdi fused industrial blended music, the mêlée erupts. The warriors clash with handmade weapons of olde, until the mighty fall, the battlefield stunned quiet, and inevitable to the Victor, the spoils…Wow! Cool! But wait then fast forward 16 years later…and what do you have left? The other 2 hours and 53 minutes of the mire (loosely called a film) to trudge through.
Unfortunately the rest of this Martin Scorsese (directed) and Jay Cocks' (screenplay) tale doesn't make much sense. The characters are all overly absorbed in their own little pathetically unimportant existence's, none of which are in the least bit interesting by themselves let alone collectively. The main element that fuels the flames of the story is "Revenge". But, that itself is reduce to a waning ember, by the obviously mounting lack of plausible motives for our hero Amsterdam Vallon (played by Leonardo DiCaprio) to extract his retaliation that was practically his birthright. The film now beholds to the idea that you almost can't help but respect and admire the reverence the villain; William 'Bill the Butcher' Cutting (played by Daniel Day Lewis) holds for his fallen adversary by his own hand low those many years previous. Thus losing any inkling of a basis for vendetta. But wait, to make things worse, it's as if the filmmaker's just said, "Oh yeah…by the way, we should probably find some way to get back to that vengeance thing." And of course they get miserably lost along the way and the film just falls apart at the seams. There are no real understandable reasons why anyone is doing anything anymore. The only thing I do understand is that this movie's script should have had stayed back in 1978 where it came from, and taken the same ill-fated route of "Heaven's Gate".
One (and the only) bright and shining note in the movie was the outstanding performance given Daniel Day Lewis as William 'Bill the Butcher' Cutting. Simply riveting. Bravo! And if they could give him and Robin Williams (One Hour Photo) "Best Actor" Oscars this year, what a wonderful world this truly would be. : )

Lyn

Here's what Jef thought...

 

 
       

 

HOME | About This Site | Recent Reviews | Movies A-Z | DVD/Videos | Guest Reviews | Links | Contact Us

© www.Film-Critiques.com - For personal use only. All rights reserved. Other marks, names, and titles are property of their respective owners.
Last updated: Thursday, January 2, 2003 5:41 PM